Bonhoeffer: When Do You Take the Wheel?
Dietrich Bonhoeffer was a man who believed in the Perverse Core of Jesus Teaching in the Sermon on the Mount—radical love, enemy forgiveness, turning the other cheek. And yet, this same man found himself part of a plot to assassinate Adolf Hitler. How does that happen? How does a pacifist theologian move from preaching peace to planning violence?
The question isn’t abstract. It’s the kind of moral tension that can break a person. And Bonhoeffer felt it deeply.
The Madman Driving the Car
Bonhoeffer once told a story to illustrate his moral struggle:
Imagine you see a madman driving a car down a crowded street, mowing down innocent people. You could jump in and pull bodies from the road, treating the wounded, praying for justice. That’s charity. That’s good.
But at some point, you realize the carnage won’t stop until someone grabs the wheel and stops the driver.
Bonhoeffer spent years trying to rescue the victims. He preached. He resisted. He helped smuggle Jews out of Germany. He tried to stand firm in faith, hoping that nonviolent resistance would be enough. But eventually, he saw that Hitler wasn’t just another political problem. He was the madman at the wheel.
And so Bonhoeffer—the pastor, the theologian, the pacifist—chose to help take that driver down.
The Perverse Core of Christian Ethics
Bonhoeffer knew the Sermon on the Mount. He believed in its impossible demands. He knew that Jesus calls us to love our enemies, not kill them. And yet, here he was, conspiring against a man he believed to be pure evil.
Does this mean he abandoned Jesus’ teaching? Or does it mean he understood it more deeply?
The perverse core of Jesus’ teaching isn’t that it hands us easy moral answers—it’s that it destabilizes them. The Sermon on the Mount pushes morality to its breaking point. It calls us to a love so radical it seems impossible. It exposes the fact that we will always fall short, forcing us to wrestle with grace, failure, and the unbearable weight of ethical responsibility.
Bonhoeffer wasn’t naive. He knew that stepping into the world of political violence would stain him. He was not looking for self-righteous justification. He was stepping into what he called “guilt-bearing responsibility”—acting, knowing that he would have to answer for it before God.
Faith That Acts—Even in the Dark
Bonhoeffer’s choice reminds us that faith is not about moral purity; it is about moral courage. His decision was not about being right—it was about being responsible. He was not seeking a clear conscience; he was accepting the reality that sometimes, doing nothing is the greater sin.
For Bonhoeffer, faith was not about avoiding guilt but embracing the burden of action in a broken world.
And that is the tension we all live in.
When do you pray for peace, and when do you act against evil? When do you trust that love can transform an enemy, and when do you stop them before they destroy more lives?
There are no easy answers. There never have been.
Bonhoeffer grabbed the wheel. And it cost him everything.
But maybe, just maybe, that’s what costly grace looks like.
We may have to face and answer the Bonhoeffer Dilemma ourselves with only a simple Yes or No.
