It doesn’t begin with certainty. It begins, almost always, with a feeling—
that something has shifted.
That what once held the world together no longer does.

Sometimes it comes like thunder—9/11, a war, a burning planet.
Other times, it’s quieter: a church door closing behind you for the last time,
a prayer that doesn’t land,
a silence that no longer feels holy.

We don’t always know how to name it, but philosophers and theologians have tried.
John Caputo calls it the event—not an answer, not a solution,
but a rupture.
A disturbance that doesn’t ask for belief,
only that you feel the tremor,
and wonder what comes next.

Some say we are living through an eschatological moment.
Not the end of the world,
but maybe the end of something.
An epoch, an era,
a way of being that no longer makes sense.

The collapse is not only institutional—though churches do sit emptier,
and trust in leaders bleeds out by the hour.
It’s internal.
It’s existential.
We are not sure how to live, or even who we are,
when the old maps don’t work anymore.

That’s where the perverse core of Jesus’ teaching begins to show itself.
Not in moral comfort.
Not in divine certainty.
But in that strange moment when his words hit differently—
like they’re less about piety and more about disruption.

“Blessed are the poor.”
“Love your enemies.”
“Do not resist an evildoer.”

These are not gentle suggestions for a spiritual life.
They are acts of resistance.
Not against people,
but against power, ego, empire, self-preservation.

They are the DNA of a different kind of life,
but not one you can live without something first falling apart.

When Christianity was legalized in 313 CE,
many early believers didn’t throw a party.
They left.
Into the wilderness, into caves, into the silence.
They weren’t trying to start a movement.
They were simply trying to keep something alive—
something they feared would be drowned in approval and prestige.

That wasn’t strategy.
It was instinct.
A response to an event.

And maybe that’s what’s happening again.

Some people bake bread.
Some people gather in silence.
Some share houses, pray the hours, or sit in living rooms with nothing but doubt and leftover wine.

They don’t do this because they’ve figured it out.
They do it because the world cracked open,
and they were left holding the pieces of a faith
that no longer fit inside the box it came in.

This is not a call to action.
It’s not even a call.

It’s a recognition.
That in the rubble,
beneath the ruins,
the perverse core still pulses—
disruptive, impossible, beautiful.

A reminder that our story has always been this:
to be human is to lose, and love anyway.
To be shattered, and still say “yes.”
To live as if the impossible might still be worth trying.

We don’t need a label.
We don’t need a movement.

But if you’re here,
and you’ve felt the rupture—
maybe this is enough.

Not an answer.
Not a plan.

Just a place to begin again.
Where the crack is.
Where the light gets in.

See:

Beyond the Threshold The Posture for New Monasticism Part 2

This essay seves as part of the ‘Perverse Core of Jesus Teaching’ material for this site.