Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s decision to participate in the plot to assassinate Hitler stands as one of the most complex ethical dilemmas in modern theology. Given his deep commitment to the Sermon on the Mount—particularly its radical nonviolence—his involvement in an act of political resistance that included assassination might seem contradictory at first glance. However, when viewed through the lens of what we’ve explored as the perverse core of Jesus’ teaching, his choice becomes an even more profound theological paradox.

The Sermon on the Mount: An Impossible Ethic?

Bonhoeffer, like many before him, saw the Sermon on the Mount as central to Christian discipleship. His book The Cost of Discipleship famously critiques “cheap grace”—grace without cost, without transformation, without suffering. He insisted that Jesus’ words were not just lofty ideals but real commands meant to be lived, no matter how impractical or extreme they seemed.

Yet the Sermon on the Mount, as we have explored, presents an ethic that is radical to the point of destabilization. “Turn the other cheek,” “love your enemies,” “do not resist an evildoer”—these are not moral suggestions but total inversions of the logic of power and self-preservation They almost demand that followers refuse all forms of self-defence, let alone political violence.

This raises the core tension in Bonhoeffer’s own life: Is there ever a point at which radical nonviolence becomes inadequate to resist evil? And if so, what does that say about Jesus’ teachings?

Bonhoeffer’s Moral Conflict: Beyond Legalism

Bonhoeffer did not arrive lightly at the decision to join the resistance against Hitler. His choice was not a rejection of Jesus’ teachings but a tragic recognition that in some situations, following Jesus does not mean adhering to rigid legalistic rules but engaging in an impossible moral struggle—a struggle where no choice is entirely pure.

If we apply the idea of Jesus’ “perverse core” to Bonhoeffer’s dilemma, we see that Jesus’ ethic was never meant to offer clear moral solutions—it was meant to expose the impossibility of pure righteousness and force individuals into a deeper reliance on grace. In that sense, Bonhoeffer’s decision was not about justifying violence but about stepping into an ethical space where he accepted the consequences of his actions, including potential guilt.

The Unbearable Burden of Responsibility

Unlike those who sought power or revenge, Bonhoeffer did not see his actions as righteous or justified—only necessary. His decision to participate in the conspiracy against Hitler was, in his own words, a leap into the abyss of responsibility. He believed that to refuse action in the face of overwhelming evil was itself a moral failure.

This is where Bonhoeffer embodies the paradox of the Sermon on the Mount:

  • He accepted the call to radical discipleship but also recognized that the world does not allow for clean choices.
  • He believed in divine grace but refused to use it as an excuse for inaction.
  • He embraced nonviolence as an ideal but confronted the reality of an evil so great that passivity might be complicity.

Bonhoeffer, The Perverse Core, and The Desert of the Real

If we consider Bonhoeffer through the lens of Lacan’s Desert of the Real, we see that he ultimately found himself outside of comforting illusions—whether theological, political, or moral. There was no way to “win” in this scenario. Either choice—resisting Hitler non-violently or conspiring against him—came with ethical and spiritual cost.

Jesus’ ethic, radical and destabilizing, might be understood not as a rigid system of rules but as a framework that forces us to face the full consequences of our actions. Bonhoeffer did not see himself as stepping outside of Christian ethics but rather stepping deeper into their complexity, where faithfulness is not about moral certainty but about wrestling with ambiguity, failure, and grace.

Conclusion: Bonhoeffer’s Legacy and the Ongoing Challenge

Bonhoeffer’s life and choices leave us with an unsettling truth: Christian ethics, if taken seriously, will always be paradoxical, uncomfortable, and costly. He understood that to follow Jesus in the real world is to live in the tension between impossible ideals and necessary action. His willingness to bear that tension—even to the point of his own execution—marks him as one of the most radical figures of modern Christianity.

In the end, Bonhoeffer did not attempt to justify his actions as righteous. Instead, he lived within the question: What does faithfulness look like when every option leads to suffering?

Perhaps the perverse core of Jesus’ teaching is not that it offers easy moral clarity but that it confronts us with the impossibility of purity, forcing us to act anyway—with courage, humility, and an acceptance of grace.

See:

Bonhoeffer Martyr or Murderer?

This essay seves as part of the ‘Perverse Core of Jesus Teaching’ material for this site.