New Monasticism in the UK did not begin as a theoretical movement, a lifestyle brand, or an experiment in alternative spirituality. It began with personal and systemic rupture. Its theological heartbeat was Bonhoeffer. Its catalyst was The Death of God. Its driving question was the one Jacques Ellul posed: “The last but most important thing about the post-Christian society is that it feels as if it has experienced Christianity and left it behind.” In response, we asked: How then shall we live?

In the early 1980s, before the phrase “New Monasticism” had cultural currency, a small group found themselves in exile—geographically and spiritually. A forced resignation following the reporting of clerical sexual abuse became the crucible in which something new was forged. John and Linda Skinner, already being shaped by Bonhoeffer’s notion of a “New Type of Monasticism,” relocated to Northumberland. With Andy Raine joining them, the foundation of what would become the Northumbria Community began to take root.

From the beginning, this was not a lifestyle movement—it was survival.

“We worked with our hands—gardening, window cleaning—not out of principle, but necessity. We were not in solidarity with the poor. We were the poor. We created informal daily prayer liturgies—short, unpolished, real—because we needed rhythm to steady ourselves amid existential collapse. We adopted monastic practices not out of nostalgia, but because they helped us not go mad.*

These practices—availability, vulnerability, hospitality, prayer—became our anchor. But they were never ends in themselves. They were a response to the disintegration of traditional Christianity, the experience of exile from institutional belonging, and the call to live meaningfully in a post-Christian society.

By the early 1990s, we had formalized this into a Rule of Life: A Way for Living. The Northumbria Community took shape as a dispersed community with a mother house and local expressions across the UK, Europe, and later, the USA and Australia. We began to host retreats for emigres and refuge for the traumatised and the troubled. Our prayer liturgy, Celtic Daily Prayer, became a trusted companion to thousands.

But NM UK was never simply about contemplation. Our mission was Monastery and Mission. We formed teams to travel across the UK Europe and the USA—working in churches, schools, communities, prisons, and urban streets. We addressed the primal question How then shall we live? through dance, drama literature, street theatre, and theological and cultural research. We were quiet but not passive.  We were trusted with significant major funding to reflect and report on spiritual and culture shifts.

Through it all, we were invisible by design. Our ethos resisted platforming. But that invisibility came at a cost. Leadership transitions led to a shift in tone and direction. The political edge softened. The prophetic impulse quieted. At times, the founding stories were pushed aside. Even still, the DNA remained. Today, hundreds of companions and  friends continue to live by the Rule: A Way for Living.

We have always known that NM UK had always contained a second, more volatile movement—what is now called the Non-Church. A response to the same Event, but further along the path. If New Monasticism offered post-Christian spiritual practices, the Non-Church held space for those for whom even belief itself had collapsed. Together, they form a theological arc. A journey from exile to presence to absence—and still, community.

We are not seeking to reclaim legacy. But we are bearing witness to the roots. The early years of NM UK were marked by honesty, risk, prayer, protest, and exile. They remain an invitation. To anyone asking not what New Monasticism is, but why it exists: this is one beginning.

Eyewitness Origins of New Monasticism (Part 2): New Monastics USA

If the UK expression of New Monasticism grew out of disillusionment with institutional religion and a yearning for post-Christian rhythms, the American story unfolded in a different climate: post-9/11 anxiety, suburban excess, evangelical burnout, and growing political fatigue. Here, the fire was not only spiritual but social—and young Christians felt it burning.

Shane Claiborne, Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove, and a loose-knit band of seekers weren’t looking for a movement. They were looking for a way to live.

Their questions weren’t abstract. They were immediate. Urgent.

How can we follow Jesus in a culture that worships money, power, and military might? How do we live out the Sermon on the Mount—not just believe in it? Where does faith belong in a country waging war overseas and turning away from the poor?

In the late 1990s, Shane helped form The Simple Way in Philadelphia—a small community of believers choosing to live in solidarity with their neighbours in a struggling urban neighbourhood. Around the same time, Rutba House was founded in Durham, North Carolina, by Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove and others. Neither was launching a movement. They were creating homes that could hold protest, hospitality, prayer, and resistance all in the same breath.

They weren’t starting churches. They weren’t building ministries. They were doing something stranger: reimagining intentional Christian community in a fractured, exhausted society. They began to articulate the shared DNA of what was emerging—what eventually became the 12 Marks of New Monasticism.

Their influences were wide-ranging: the Anabaptists, Dorothy Day and the Catholic Worker Movement, Franciscan poverty, Bonhoeffer’s Cost of Discipleship, and the burning call of the Sermon on the Mount.

Unlike the Northumbria Community’s contemplative, Celtic, and liturgical foundation, New Monastics USA was shaped by protest, civil disobedience, urban poverty, and the sharp edges of post-evangelical culture. Where the UK built dispersed rhythms of prayer and inward resistance, the USA built communal houses of welcome, outward resistance, and the daily practice of radical hospitality.

Both expressions were born from crisis.

Both were trying to follow Jesus in the ruins.

Both made different choices—but choices that mirror each other across the ocean.

And now? The fires are still burning. New Monasticism in the USA continues to evolve—less a unified movement, more a shared imagination for what faith can look like outside the consumer church, in the shadows of empire.

As in the UK, there’s no headquarters. No marketing plan. No brand strategy.

Just scattered communities. Loosely connected. Rooted in place. Holding on to something fierce and fragile:

That maybe, just maybe, the Beatitudes weren’t poetic idealism.

Maybe they’re a blueprint.

A whisper.

A call.

See:

New Monasticism and The Non-Church

This essay seves as part of the ‘ New Monasticism’ material for this site.